Cafe Italiano at the Sweet Shop is a beloved, local-family-owned Buchanan tradition—serving the community since 1947. Set in a historic downtown landmark, Cafe Italiano blends old-fashioned charm with fresh, authentic flavor, featuring a beautifully restored vintage 1936 soda fountain. From scratch-made Italian favorites to classic American soda-counter treats, Cafe Italiano focuses on premium ingredients: locally sourced when possible & imported from Italy when authenticity demands. Whether joining us for lunch, dinner, dessert, or a family-fun outing, you’ll find warm hospitality, attentive service, and a stunning interior that makes every visit special. Premium Hot & Cold subs, Pizzas, Pastas, Ice Cream, Cannoli, Cakes, Speciality Drinks